A Critique
D.J. Conway is a prolific author who has
researched many aspects of magick; however, this book falls short - on
its face, in fact - when it comes to Dragon Magick. While Ms. Conway
does a good job of recounting the lore of dragons from various cultures,
her explanations and conclusions based on this lore are the uninspired
product of an uninitiated perspective. While Ms. Conway has done a good
job of wedding Dragon lore and pagan magick, this combination does not
constitute genuine Dragon Magick. The supposed personal experiences with
dragons which Ms. Conway sprinkles liberally throughout her book show
that she is without a clue when it comes to the true nature of the
Dragon.
One can get a feel for the tenor of the book
without actually having to critique it page by page. A brief analysis of
the first page one sees after opening the cover pretty well summarizes
the entire book. This page is titled, 'Enter the Mouth of the Dragon.'
Let's examine some of the statements here:
(1) "they live on the astral plane"
The astral plane is one of many planes in our universe, which is one of
many universes. The Dragon exists outside of all of these as one of the
primal forces arising from Chaos before anything else existed. The
Dragon is not a resident of the astral plane, and one will not find the
Dragon hanging out there - although contact may occasionally be made
with the Dragon on the astral.
(2) "Dragons have control of… elemental energies"
Elemental energies are the manifestation of the activity of inorganic
beings typically referred to as elementals, and have nothing to do with
the Dragon.
(3) "dragons make excellent protectors and powerful fellow
magicians"
The eldest of the ancient primal gods has no interest in protecting
humans or being a "fellow magician."
(4) "This is the first book ever to provide complete dragon
rituals…"
All of the magick presented in this book is common pagan magick which
has nothing to do with the Dragon. Dragon magick is knowledge received
directly from the Dragon; it always concerns personal transformation and
always refers to magick that can only be performed in other spheres by
one who has already spent many years undergoing personal transformation
on the Path of initiation.
(5)"…the many types of dragons…"
There are not "many types of dragons." The Dragon is a singular force
that has been only vaguely apprehended by initiates throughout human
history.
Now let's look at the poem following the title
page, from which the book apparently takes its title, 'Dancing Dragons.'
That which dances, i.e., has motion, characterizes the phenomenal
universe, the manifested universe which emerged from the Abyss. The
noumena, that which is above the Abyss, is motionless and thus does not
'dance.' That part of the Dragon which manifests does indeed dance;
however, this dance can only be compared to the Dance of Shiva, by which
Shiva creates and destroys whole universes. This poem is wholly
inadequate to represent this concept, and inaccurately represents the
Dragon's intent - which is not "to dance with joy life's plan," but to
transcend it. The poem ends by asking the Dragon to teach the poet "to
lift myself to higher planes." Unfortunately, one can only make contact
with the Dragon after one has learned to do this on one's own, or
after one has learned to manipulate Time itself.
In sum, this book is largely
a piece of pagan fluff and nonsense, with none of the High Magick
characteristic of true Dragon Magick. Somehow Ms. Conway has confused an
ancient primal force of Chaos which has created whole universes and Time
itself with the elemental spirits that any housewife can command. I did
like the illustrations, though.